ErraticErrata's A Practical Guide to Evil was one of the most ambitious web serials ever completed — seven books, a fully realized fantasy world, and a protagonist whose moral descent was examined with uncomfortable precision. Following that is difficult. Pale Lights doesn't try to be PGTE. It's smaller, stranger, and in some ways better.
What it is
Pale Lights takes place in a world beneath a dying sun. The light is fading. The dark is expanding. In this twilight, an organization operates in the shadows — part spy network, part monster-hunting order, part political instrument.
The story follows two protagonists: Tristan, a thief who survived a massacre and carries a debt of guilt, and Angharad, a disgraced noble from a fallen house who carries a sword and a tremendous amount of pride. Both are recruited into the shadowy organization. Both are given impossible tasks.
What makes it work
The prose is a step up. PGTE was well-written but sometimes functional — it moved the plot at the cost of stylistic grace. Pale Lights is written with more care. Descriptions are tighter. Dialogue crackles. ErraticErrata's voice has matured, and you can feel it in every chapter.
The dual protagonist structure works. Tristan and Angharad are different kinds of sympathetic. Tristan is charming, desperate, and haunted. Angharad is rigid, honorable, and brittle. Their chapters alternate, and each perspective enriches the other. You root for both of them while understanding that their goals may not be compatible.
The worldbuilding is parsimonious. Pale Lights gives you just enough to understand the world — the dying sun, the shadowy organization, the political factions — and trusts you to figure out the rest. There's no lore-dumping. There's no appendix. The world reveals itself through the characters' experience of it, which is how good fantasy worldbuilding works.
The tension is character-driven. The external threats — monsters, rival agents, political enemies — are real, but the most interesting conflicts are internal. Tristan's guilt. Angharad's pride. The growing recognition that the organization they serve may not be benevolent. The story earns its dramatic moments through character work rather than plot escalation.
Who it's for
If you liked A Practical Guide to Evil for its moral complexity and sharp dialogue, Pale Lights delivers both in a tighter package. If you bounced off PGTE's length or its later-book pacing, Pale Lights might be a better entry point — it's more contained and the prose is stronger.
If you like dark fantasy that earns its darkness — not grimdark for shock value, but stories that take their characters' suffering seriously — this is one of the best ongoing serials in the medium.
Available on the author's website and SpaceBattles. Weekly updates.